Cleansing Oil vs. Balm: Which is Better For Double Cleansing?

A bottle of the Pili Ani Gentle Facial Cleanser placed beside a towel, vase, and mirror Pili Ani Gentle Facial Cleanser, $32.

For many, skincare routines are straightforward: start with an effective cleanser and toner, then follow up with the rest of your regimen. However, some skincare enthusiasts prefer double cleansing, which involves washing your face twice before moving on to the next steps.

Deciding whether to cleanse once or twice is crucial, as it sets the foundation for healthy, glowing skin. This choice also helps you determine the best type of cleanser for your skin type. It's a popular debate in the skincare community—cleansing oil vs balm, which one is better?

Today, we're here to guide you through the essentials of double cleansing and help you decide between cleansing oils and balms.

Your Quick Guide to a Double Cleanse

We know that double cleansing means washing your face twice. But it’s so much more than that—it also depends on the cleansers you use.

When double cleansing your face, begin with an oil-based product, then rinse and follow up with a water-based cleanser. This method effectively removes waterproof makeup, sunscreen, and excess oil, even for those with oily skin. Starting with an oil-based cleanser ensures that water-based cleansers can work more effectively, allowing your other skincare products to penetrate deeper for optimal results.

How to Double Cleanse the Face

Ready to try double cleansing? Here’s how:

  1. Apply an oil-based cleanser to your palm and gently massage it into your skin to remove excess makeup, oil, and sunscreen.
  2. Rinse the formula with a washcloth or lukewarm water.
  3. With your skin still damp, apply a water-based cleanser and gently massage it into your face to cleanse any remaining impurities.
  4. Rinse thoroughly and pat your skin dry with a soft towel.

Should I Double Cleanse Every Day?

Another common question about double cleansing is whether it should be part of your daily routine. The answer largely depends on your skin type and how often you wear makeup.

For starters, double cleansing every evening can work wonders for those with oily skin or who wear makeup daily. Removing makeup, excess oil, and impurities helps keep your skin clear and balanced.

If you have normal skin or rarely use cosmetics, incorporating a gentle cleanser into your regimen might be sufficient. It ensures your skin remains clean without over-stripping its natural oils.

However, if you have sensitive skin concerns such as rosacea, eczema, or generally dry and sensitive skin, double cleansing might not be the best approach. This practice can potentially dry out your skin further or exacerbate existing conditions. In these cases, sticking to a single, gentle cleanser that hydrates and soothes is a better choice for maintaining your skin's health and comfort.

Ultimately, listening to your skin and adjusting your cleansing routine to what feels best for you is the key.

A Closer Look at Cleansing Oils & Balms

There are many types of double-cleansing cleansers on the market, including cleansing oils and balms. Now, you may ask, how do both products work?

Cleansing oils are your go-to for removing makeup and sunscreen. They’re formulated with botanical oils that effectively mix with water to cleanse your skin thoroughly. To clear away excess makeup and sunscreen, cleansing oils should be massaged into your skin in a circular motion. This helps break down and lift impurities, leaving your skin refreshed and prepped for the next steps in your routine.

On the other hand, cleansing balms offer a luxurious, three-in-one solution for your skincare routine. Their rich, creamy texture transforms into a silky oil as you massage it onto your skin, melting away makeup, dirt, and impurities. When you add water, the balm turns into a milky emulsion, ensuring a thorough cleanse without any hassle.

What are the Pros & Cons of Cleansing Oils & Balms?

Cleansing oils and balms have numerous benefits and drawbacks. Here's what you need to consider when choosing the right product for a double cleanse:

The Advantages of Cleansing Oils

  • Cleansing oils are a fantastic choice for all skin types, from normal to combination, as they clean effectively without stripping away moisture.
  • These cleansers also come in pump bottles, ensuring a long shelf life and easy application.
  • When you need to remove makeup quickly, cleansing oils are your go-to for speedy and efficient results.
  • Their versatility extends beyond your skin—use them to clean your makeup brushes as well, making them a true multitasker in your skincare routine.

The Disadvantages of Cleansing Oils

  • Remember that cleansing oils are often packaged in bottles, which can be a hassle for travel. They’re prone to spills and may be restricted at airports.
  • For some, cleansing oils can feel too heavy or potentially cause breakouts, especially if applied generously. To minimize this risk, apply the oil carefully to areas like your hairline, chin, and nostrils.
  • These cleansers excel at removing long-wear makeup and sunscreen but some may feel too heavy for specific skin types.

The Advantages of Cleansing Balms

  • Cleansing balms, like their oil-based counterparts, are a versatile choice for every skin type.
  • They’re gentle enough to soothe dry and sensitive skin, reducing redness and irritation while balancing natural oils.
  • Perfect for those with acne-prone skin, these balms offer hydration, oil control, and a refreshing cleanse.
  • They’re the ideal companion for a luxurious self-care ritual, making them a must-have for unwinding after a long day.

The Disadvantages of Cleansing Balms

  • Cleansing balms, while wonderfully effective, may require more frequent replenishment as you use them.
  • They demand a bit more effort compared to cleansing oils: expect to spend a few extra minutes applying and rinsing with a clean cloth.
  • The rich hydration provided by balms can sometimes feel a touch heavy on the skin.

Clear Away Impurities with a Gentle & Nourishing Cleanser

When deciding between cleansing oil vs balm, consider what fits best with your skincare routine and lifestyle. Both types offer unique benefits for a double cleanse, so the key is to experiment and find which one aligns with your needs. Look for cleansers that boast effective, nourishing ingredients for optimal results.

For a gentle yet powerful option, explore Pili Ani’s Gentle Facial Cleanser. Infused with rare and potent Elemi Oil, this all-natural formula combines the versatility of oils with the luxurious hydration of balms – designed to not only help reduce breakouts but also deeply clean, calm, and balance your skin. Visit our website to shop our Gentle Facial Cleanser and discover more tips for radiant, healthy skin on our blog.